Ann Clark Cookie Cutters' number 1 cutter is the venerable gingerbread man. But even the G-man is only produced in runs of 500 at a time, maybe four times a week − not 40,000 in inventory.

“There are really only three major cookie cutter factories left in the United States, and we’re one of those three.” Off the Beaten Path, which is also known by cookiecutter.com, has seven ...

To be honest, I wasn’t expecting there to be such a clear winner, but one of these cookie cutter sets performed so much better than the rest it’s the only one we really need to talk about.