Anna Newlin, who once lived with the Mans family, defends the Mans family on camera, but then suggests to producers of the show that Natalia was struck with a belt and kicked down a flight of stairs by the Manses. "There's some things that can land [Cynthia] and Antwon in jail for a long time," she says in a voiceover.

The third season of the ID channel docuseries brings to light allegations of financial and physical abuse against Natalia’s new adoptive parents, Antwon and Cynthia Mans; THR reached out to the Indiana Police Department about the allegations.