Kristina Bumphrey/Variety via Getty; Monica Schipper/Getty James Marsden might have played it cool, but he was definitely crushing on Neve Campbell when they worked together on Party of Five.

Apple TV+ Krys Marshall is just like Us — and seriously fangirled when she found out she was playing James Marsden’s love interest on the new Hulu series, Paradise. “Like cartoon wolf, [with] eyeballs ...