Carrie Underwood has taken a look back at her American Idol audition as she makes her debut as a judge on the hit singing competition.

Back when she auditioned for American Idolin 2005, Carrie Underwood arrived at her Kansas City casting event every bit the homegrown Oklahoma farm girl. She was country through and through, and had grown up in the ’90s,

American Idol judges reveal which songs they’re tired of hearing, from “It’s a Man’s World” to “Watermelon Sugar,” urging contestants to get creative.